Is Restoring Old Furniture Worth It?

Antique Furniture Restoring

That piece of furniture sitting in your attic or passed down from your grandmother might be more than just a sentimental item. It could be a valuable asset waiting for a new lease on life. Many people wonder if it’s worth the effort to fix up an old dresser or dining table. The answer is often a resounding yes.

As a general rule, any piece of furniture in good condition that passes through two generations starts increasing in value.

A generation is typically about 20 to 25 years. This means that furniture from our parents’ and grandparents’ eras is now appreciating. Before you replace that dated-looking piece with a modern alternative, let’s explore why restoring it is often the smarter, more sustainable, and more valuable choice.

The Lost Art of Quality Furniture

Have you noticed the term “retro” popping up in furniture stores? Manufacturers are trying to replicate the styles of past decades. However, these reproductions rarely match the originals in quality. The truth is, furniture will likely never again be made with the solid construction or high-quality materials used in pieces from previous generations.

As a company who has worked with furniture for years, we generally will not restore any piece less than 25 years old. Around that time, much of the industry shifted. Many manufacturers began building furniture with pressboard, sawdust mixed with glue, and inferior woods like poplar and rubberwood. We have witnessed the quality of mass-produced furniture decline to the point where it is often little more than firewood with a pretty finish. These pieces are designed to be disposable, not to last.

In contrast, older furniture was built to endure. The craftsmanship, design, and high-end woods used are simply not standard in today’s market.

What Makes Older Furniture Better?

When you’re deciding whether to restore a piece, it helps to know what signs of quality to look for. These details are what set true vintage items apart from their modern, mass-produced counterparts.

Solid Wood vs Veneer and Pressboard

The most significant difference is the material. Older furniture is often made from solid hardwoods like oak, walnut, cherry, and mahogany. These woods are durable, strong, and can be sanded and refinished multiple times. You can identify solid wood by looking at the edge of a tabletop or drawer front. If the grain pattern wraps around from the top to the side, it’s likely solid wood.

Modern, cheaper furniture frequently uses pressboard or particleboard—wood particles glued together—covered with a thin layer of wood veneer or laminate. While this keeps costs down, these materials are easily damaged by moisture and cannot be repaired or refinished in the same way as solid wood.

Superior Joinery

How a piece of furniture is held together is another indicator of its quality. Look for traditional joinery techniques, which create strong, lasting bonds.

  • Dovetail Joints: Interlocking pins and tails, often seen on the corners of drawers, are a hallmark of high-quality construction.
  • Mortise and Tenon Joints: A post (tenon) is fitted into a hole (mortise) to form a strong, right-angle joint, common in table and chair frames.

Newer, mass-produced items often rely on staples, screws, and glue, which can loosen and fail over time.

Why Restoration is a Smart Choice

Choosing to restore an old piece of furniture offers several powerful benefits over buying new.

  • Economic Value: Restoring a high-quality vintage piece is often cheaper than buying a new, solid-wood equivalent. Furthermore, you are investing in an item that will not only last but also continue to appreciate in value.
  • Sustainability: Keeping furniture out of the landfill is an environmentally friendly choice. Restoration honors the resources—the wood, the labor, the history—that went into the original piece. Moreover, you are recycling in the most elegant way possible.
  • Unmatched Character: A restored piece has a story. The patina, the unique grain, and the classic design bring a depth and warmth to your home that brand-new furniture simply cannot replicate.

What Should Your Restore? A Quick Guide

Not every old item is a hidden gem. Here’s a simple checklist to help you decide.

Consider Restoring If:

  • It’s made of solid wood.
  • The piece has “good bones” and is structurally sound, even if the finish is worn.
  • It features quality joinery like dovetails.
  • It has sentimental value to your family.

Consider Replacing If:

  • It is made primarily of pressboard or particleboard.
  • It has severe structural damage, like extensive rot or pest infestation, that would be too costly to repair.
  • The piece has no unique design or sentimental value.

So treasure the furniture of your previous family generations.  Restore it, Repair it, treat it with love.  There will never again be any furniture produced  with this  fine woodworking, design and  high end woods.

~ Best, Betty.